Improving the evidence for buffer strip effectiveness across the Demonstration Test Catchments

Riparian buffers can be effective at removing sediment and phosphorus (P) from overland flow originating from agricultural land and therefore can be a useful tool in ameliorating diffuse pollution, as well as providing other benefits such as biodiverse habitats.  Consequently, they are included as an important land management option under Environmental Stewardship. However, to date the functioning and efficiency of buffer strips is relatively poorly understood, including their effectiveness over time. This is important because buffers which have accrued P could themselves potentially become a source of P should erosion of the buffer itself occur. The timescales over which buffer efficiency changes is uncertain, and will vary depending on many factors including land use and soil type. A collaborative project (Defra WQ0208) between ADAS and Rothamsted Research, led by Prof. Adrian Collins (ADAS, Avon Catchment Consortium Leader), with Dr Martin Blackwell, Ms Rachel Matthews and Dr David Chadwick (Rothamsted Research) and Ms Sophie Sherriff, Ms Leasa Williams and Ms Sarah Smith (ADAS) has been investigating the effectiveness and potential longevity of buffer strips for sediment and nutrient (especially phosphorus) removal from runoff from agricultural land across all three DTC catchments.

Four sites with similar soils, slopes, land use (in this case arable) and buffers of comparable widths but different ages were selected in each catchment. Soil samples from the upslope fields (all arable) and across the buffer strips were collected (Figure 1) in both summer 2010 and winter 2010/11 and analysed for a range of parameters including different forms of P. Analysis is ongoing, but preliminary data show that for some forms of P, the buffers could potentially be saturated and effectively leaking P, and that this is likely to be related to age. However, final conclusions cannot be made until all data has been compiled, analysed and assessed. This project will provide useful information on the effectiveness and potential life-span of buffers, and help develop policy on buffer design (e.g. width) and management for the future.

Figure 1: Collecting soil samples from a 6m wide buffer strip in the Eden catchment


Figure 2: Preliminary data showing the distribution in cross sections of water soluble total P across two CSS buffer strips in the Hampshire Avon catchment (field boundary on left, water body boundary on right). Darker colours represent higher concentrations, and the charts on the right show the absolute values at each depth. These data indicate that the water soluble P is at a maximum concentration at the downslope buffer edge, suggesting it may be leaching into the adjacent surface water body.



2 thoughts on “Improving the evidence for buffer strip effectiveness across the Demonstration Test Catchments

  1. Richard

    Could these results be due to the fact that there is no offtake (cropping) from the buffer strip…hence the high concentrations compared to the field… rather than the strip aborbing runoff.

    What is the soil type and hydrology across the field? i.e. how is water moving across the field…overland flow or through flow?

  2. Charlotte Lemmon

    How are you relating buffer strip management with age: is there a link between removing vegetation or not ? 6m margins in ELS require that the 3m closest to the crop is annually cut. Would be useful information for option design.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *